To Top

Five Underground LGBT Musicals You Have To See

When you’ve watched Rent and Hedwig one too many times, here’s what you should see next.

1. Normativity

Don’t you hate it when your favorite gay and lesbian characters die? For no reason?

Young lesbian Taylor has had enough of the #BuryYourGays media trend – and Emily, a book character who has come alive, needs to convince her author not to spare her life. Love, hijinks and plot twists abound. If you’re straight, you won’t be after seeing Madeline Wolf do a stunning performance as Emily.


This meta musical will send your head spinning as you question the line between reality and fiction. Are you actually a book character? Or are you secretly an author? Can you be both? This philosophical bender is paired with a hilarious, upbeat score that will stick in your head for days.

Where to watch it: Normativity premiered July 2016 in New York at the New York Musical Festival. More NYC dates will be added soon.

2. Straight Outta Oz

A cross between The Wizard of Oz and Beyonce’s Lemonade, this haunting retelling is darker, funnier and more honest than anything L. Frank Baum had in mind. Broadway star Todrick Hall created this musical to detail his personal journey as a gay artist.

maxresdefault (22)

The tone of the show varies wildly. One minute, you’ll feel goosebumps as a deranged Wizard sings, “Pay no attention/To the man behind the curtain/He’s a brainless, heartless coward.” The next, you’ll be dancing with drag queens to electronica: “Hello, I’m rich, nice to meet ya/I got a new friend and his name Mr. Visa.”


This creative show will keep you on your toes, and is hilarious from opening to closing curtain.

Where to watch it: Online for free on Todrick’s official YouTube channel. Or see it live in Los Angeles in September.

3. Liberty’s Secret

What if Sarah Palin realized she were a lesbian? Then she’d star in Liberty’s Secret. Liberty, the running mate to a floundering conservative presidential candidate, is an all-American girl. She could not be more American unless she were born on the fourth of July.


But then she falls for her female spin doctor…

We’ve all heard the phrase, “Love wins.” But will Liberty’s political campaign?


Where to watch it: This show premieres Sept 22 in Ann Arbor, Michigan at Michigan Theatre.

4. Were the World Mine

Since scholars debate Shakespeare’s possible bi- or homosexuality, you’d think his plays would have more LGBTQ characters – Were the World Mine, a gay retelling of A Midsummer Night’s Dream, fills that gap. It tells the tale of Timothy, a small town gay teen who uses a potion to win the heart of his rugby jock crush.


The show doesn’t necessarily tread any new territory, but with songs like “Dodgeball Daydream,” it’s a fun romp through a fantastical world.

Where to watch it: Rent it from Vimeo for $3.99.

5. Fun Home

Okay, so Fun Home won Best Tony in 2015, so it’s not exactly underground. However, it’s so good that it can’t not be on this list. When you see it, you’ll know why. This comic book-turned-Broadway musical features an astounding cast, a heart-wrenching score and relatable lyrics – “I’m changing my major to Joanne,” sings Allison the protagonist, after kissing her first girl in college.


This show tells Allison’s coming-out story parallel to her father’s. Her father remained a closeted gay man for his entire life, and eventually committed suicide. The show’s title, short for Funeral Home, seems eerily fitting. This is a show of family, of grief and, most of all, of acceptance.


Where to watch it: On Broadway eight times a week until mid-September, and on a national tour starting October 2016.

Leave a Reply

More in Entertainment

  • Gillian Anderson: ‘I Could Be Dating A Woman Next Year’

    Gillian Anderson – who came out in 2012 – says she has no issue with her bisexuality Anderson – who came... StaffFebruary 5, 2018
  • Watch: Rachel McAdams, Rachel Weisz Spark Forbidden Passion In ‘Disobedience’

    Disobedience stars Rachel McAdams and Rachel Weisz as two women raised in an Orthodox Jewish community who share a forbidden romance. The... StaffFebruary 2, 2018
  • Ellen DeGeneres Moved To Tears By Wife Portia De Rossi’s Birthday Gift

    Ellen DeGeneres has just celebrated her 60th birthday in a special episode of her hit television show and was moved to... StaffFebruary 2, 2018
  • Coronation Street Actress Discusses Playing Soap’s First Lesbian Muslim Character

    Coronation Street star Bhavna Limbachia has opened up about playing the soaps first queer Muslim character. In recent months, viewers have... StaffFebruary 2, 2018
  • Megan Mullally Had No Idea Ellen DeGeneres’ Roommates Were Her Girlfriends

    Apparently, Megan Mullally had no idea Ellen DeGeneres’ roommates were her girlfriends. Will & Grace star Megan Mullally and Ellen DeGeneres have been friends for... StaffFebruary 1, 2018
  • Black Lightning’s Nafessa Williams Opens Up About Getting A New Girlfriend On The Show

    Black Lightning’s lesbian superhero just got a new girlfriend – and the actress playing her could not be more excited. CW’s... StaffFebruary 1, 2018
  • ‘Black Lightning’ Is Bringing To Life This AWESOME Lesbian Superhero

    When The CW debuts Black Lightning on January 16, they’re not just debuting a show about an all-black family of superheroes. They’re... StaffJanuary 9, 2018
  • LGBT+ A-listers Pledge To Fight Against Sexual Harassment In The Workplace

    To kick off 2018, women in Hollywood have announced a plan to fight back against sexual harassment and gender inequality in the entertainment... StaffJanuary 4, 2018
  • Ellen Page Marries Partner Emma Portner

    Hurrah, Ellen Page has tied the knot with dance instructor partner Emma Portner over the New Year. The actress shared the... StaffJanuary 4, 2018
  • Ellen DeGeneres Fires Back At Eric Trump For ‘Deep State’ Tweet

    Ellen DeGeneres made a rare foray into politics this week to take the president’s son down a notch. During her show,... StaffJanuary 4, 2018

A dedicated website for Lesbians, Bi, Trans, and Gay women; offering posts on lesbian lifestyle, LGBTQ news, lesbian film rental, health advice, lesbian dating and more...

Latest News

  • Gillian Anderson: ‘I Could Be Dating A Woman Next Year’

  • Watch: Rachel McAdams, Rachel Weisz Spark Forbidden Passion In ‘Disobedience’

  • Ellen DeGeneres Moved To Tears By Wife Portia De Rossi’s Birthday Gift

  • Coronation Street Actress Discusses Playing Soap’s First Lesbian Muslim Character

  • 10 Valentine’s Day Sex Positions For An Unforgettably Romantic Night

Most Shared Posts

  • Science Proves That Homophobia Means You’re (Probably) Gay...
    According to a study in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, homophobes are “more lik
  • The Queer Muslim Movement Is Growing...
    In America, Muslims are often depicted as intolerant and bigoted. However, more and more Muslims are
  • 31 Beautiful Lesbian Wedding Photos That Prove Two Brides Are Better T...
    We’re feeling the love here at KitschMix HQ. These stunning photos celebrate the love and joy that